📉 Resilient Trader Trade Idea: The Subprime Auto Wreck on Credit Acceptance Corp (CACC)

In partnership with

94% of Institutional Investors Are in Private Credit.

A 2025 Nuveen survey found 94% of institutional investors now allocate to private credit. Pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, endowments — it's about as close to unanimous as institutional finance gets. What they know: T. Rowe Price research shows a 10% private credit allocation has historically cut portfolio volatility and improved risk-adjusted returns. $592.8 billion deployed globally in 2024, up 78% from the year before. Accredited investors on Percent get direct access to private credit, starting at $500: · 16.72% current weighted average coupon rate · Terms as short as 3 months · Full borrower financials before you invest $1.82B funded. 0.58% lifetime charge-off rate. 97.33% of all principal returned or currently performing. New investors can receive up to $500 on their first investment.

Follow the institutional money.

^{Alternative investments are speculative. Past performance not indicative of future results. Terms apply.}

Resilient Trader is where smart traders come for vetted ideas.

Every week, we cut through the noise and surface opportunities that institutions are already eyeing - but with strategies tailored for retail traders. Today's setup? A subprime auto lender sitting on a powder keg of bad loans while a macro storm rolls in from the Middle East.

We’ll cover:

• Why Credit Acceptance Corp is a Short at current levels

• How to take advantage with defined risk through a put spread

🔍 Trade Thesis: CACC Is Driving Into a Wall of Subprime Defaults

Credit Acceptance Corp (CACC) has spent decades financing cars for people no one else will lend to. Their model is clever - they pay dealers upfront, then collect directly from borrowers. When it works, it prints money. When it doesn't, the losses pile up fast.

Right now, it's not working.

Behind the scenes:

🚨 Vintage Credit Indigestion: Their 2022–2024 loan book is badly missing initial collection forecasts. The 2022 vintage is underperforming by a staggering 8.2 percentage points - the worst miss in a decade.

⛽ Fuel Cost Shock: Gas prices are up 42% YTD following attacks on QatarEnergy's Ras Laffan LNG complex. When you're already living paycheck to paycheck, an extra $70-$100/month at the pump is the difference between making your car payment and skipping it.

🏛️ Legal Overhang: The New York Attorney General lawsuit for predatory lending is still active. The company racked up $74.2 million in contingent legal losses in 2025 alone.

📊 The Fundamentals Are Breaking Down

Let's break it down:

💰 Loan Volume: Unit volume dropped 9.1% and dollar volume fell 11.3% YoY in Q4 2025

📉 Forecast Misses: The 2022 vintage is missing collection forecasts by 8.2% - the worst in 10 years

📦 Delinquencies: Subprime auto 60-day delinquencies hit a record 6.9% in January 2026 (Fitch Ratings)

🛠️ Active Dealers Shrinking: Down 2.8% YoY - fewer dealers means fewer loans means less revenue

🧮 Leverage: Debt-to-Equity sits at a precarious 4.17x - leaving no room for error as losses mount

📐 Valuation Doesn't Reflect the Risk

CACC is priced like it's immune to the subprime storm:

⚖️ P/E Ratio: 11.45x - looks cheap until you realize earnings are inflated by lower provision releases vs. 2024

🏷️ 100% Subprime Exposure: Unlike Ally Financial or Capital One, CACC has zero diversification. When their borrowers hurt, there is nowhere to hide.

📈 Short Interest: 18.83% of the float is sold short - the smart money is already betting heavily against this stock

🧭 Technicals Agree: This Chart Looks Broken

❌ Below ALL key moving averages (20-day, 50-day, and 200-day)

❌ RSI at 33.09 - strong bearish momentum

❌ Down 21.38% over the past year, down 15% in the past month alone

🏷️ Current price: $CACC ( ▼ 0.74% ) $416.51(as of last nights close)

🎯 Targets: $383 (breakeven), $350 (max profit)

💥 Trade of the Week: Defined-Risk Put Spread

We're combining a short equity position with a defined-risk options trade for leveraged downside.

🟢 Trade Setup

• Short CACC at $416.51

🛡️ Options Play

Buy the Oct 16th 2026 $410/$350 Put Spread for $27.00

• Buy Oct 16th $410 Put: $53.00

• Sell Oct 16th $350 Put: $26.00

• Net debit: $27.00

📈 Risk-Reward

• Max Risk: $27.00

• Max Reward: $33.00

• Breakeven: $383.00

• Risk-Reward Ratio: 1:1.22

🛑 Risk Management Tip

Set a cover-stop at $435 to cap upside risk while allowing room for downside follow-through.

🚀 Catalysts on the Horizon

Keep your eyes on:

1. Q1 2026 Earnings (April 29th) - The full impact of the fuel price spike hits borrower data

2. Vintage Forecast Revisions - Each quarter 2023-2024 loans miss, expect more provision charges

3. NY AG Lawsuit - Any adverse ruling could trigger a sharp selloff

4. Technical breakdown - A close below the $401.90 52-week low could trigger accelerated selling

🧠 Final Thoughts

CACC is a classic case of a company with a clever business model running headfirst into a macro wall it cannot avoid.

From the vintage credit indigestion to the fuel cost shock squeezing their core demographic, the record delinquencies, and the broken chart - this setup has all the ingredients for a profitable short.

✅ Short CACC at $416.51
💸 Buy the $410/$350 Oct 16th Put Spread for $27.00

We'll be watching this one closely.

Want more trade ideas like this - plus weekly options plays and breakdowns?

👉 Join the Paid Resilient Trader Newsletter

For more in-depth trading strategies and market insights, upgrade to the paid version of our newsletter.

Our paid newsletter gives you:

• Weekly stock + options trade ideas

  • Market commentary and macro insights

    • Easy-to-follow setups with defined risk

Stay Liquid, my friends and Happy New Year!
- The Resilient Trader